Bad advice
Actors deliver short bits of advice on a real problem from the audience β both useful and deliberately "bad". The format trains speed of thought and timing, and fits as a quick number in a short-form show or as a training block for punchline work.
Players
2β8
Difficulty
Beginner
Full description
Setup and Launch
Line actors up in a row or semicircle. Explain the task: we take a real-life problem from the audience and respond in turn with short lines β one piece of advice at a time. Advice can be both useful and deliberately "bad"; what matters is brevity, a clear idea, and a crisp punchline.
Ask the audience for a safe, non-traumatic problem (e.g.: "I'm always late for work", "my neighbor is noisy", "I have a difficult boss"). Agree with actors: one sentence β one idea, no explanations or acted-out scenes. Coach signals: "Next!" β to the next actor, "Stop" β end the topic and take a new one.
Flow
-
Collecting the prompt. Quickly take 1β2 problems, choose the most playable, and state it verbatim so everyone hears the same formulation.
-
First wave of advice. Start from any actor and maintain a brisk pace: one piece of advice β one micro-punchline; alternate "useful" and "bad" advice for contrast.
-
Keeping order. If someone goes into explanations or a story, gently cut them off ("Short β next!"). Watch that no one monopolizes the queue, and rotation is even.
-
Acceleration and button. When the stream starts to thin (after 20β40 seconds), accelerate for 2β3 beats, catch the strongest laugh, and drop the button ("Done!") β end the round.
-
Changing the problem. Take the next prompt and repeat 2β4 rounds, rotating the starting actor for balance of voices and freshness of angles.
Key rules
One piece of advice β one short sentence. If actors start explaining, give a clear 'shorter' signal and remind them of the punchline format.
Even rotation: don't let two people run the whole show. Rotate the starter and point to 'next' if someone freezes.
Watch for variety of angles: literal, absurd, overly serious, status-based. When things repeat, ask for a change of approach.
Safety of tone: 'bad' advice is about comedic absurdity, not real dangerous instructions. Immediately veto toxic or triggering topics.
Timing over exhaustiveness: cut at the peak of laughter and change the problem every 30β60 seconds to maintain momentum.
Context
What to try next
Similar formats, so you can keep the rehearsal moving without stopping to search.
The Good, the Bad and the Ugly Advice
A short-form panel game where each audience question gets three answers in escalating order β good, bad, and truly ugly. The host assigns levels each round, and every anβ¦
Questions Only
A short-form scene game where every line must be a question. Slip up with a statement, hesitate too long, or repeat yourself, and you're immediately swapped out. Trains β¦
Ditties
A team competition in rhymed ditties, where actors wittily tease opponents in rhythm. The format trains speed of thinking, sense of tempo, and punchline delivery in a muβ¦
Options
A short-form scene where a host rings a bell to add and remove temporary constraints β options β for one or all performers. Builds flexibility, quick switching, and the β¦
Butterfly effect
A scene of two characters, periodically interrupted by their future versions who warn about consequences and redirect choices. Useful for training cause-and-effect conneβ¦
Alphabet Game
A short-form game where each line of dialogue must start with the next letter of the alphabet β 26 lines, A to Z. A sharp listening drill and a crowd-pleasing language cβ¦