Before or after

A short-form game where the opening scene becomes the anchor: the audience decides each time whether to go before or after it. The team builds causes and consequences while keeping the established canon intact.

Players

2–8

Difficulty

Beginner

Audience on stage

Yes

Full description

Setup and Launch

Get a neutral suggestion from the audience — a place, an event, a relationship. Bring out a duo or trio. They play a base scene lasting 60–120 seconds: establish who, where, and what clearly, then build to one strong turning point. No time jumps before the first cut.

Explain the canon rule: everything established in the base scene stays true for the rest of the game. After each cut the audience picks a time direction. Agree on how they'll vote (shout, applause, show of hands) and what your cut signal is (host clap, light or music cue).

Flow

The cycle repeats until the story feels complete or lands on a natural resolution. The host keeps the timeline clear and the pace of cuts brisk.

  1. Base scene. Let it reach its turning point, then cut sharply. Quickly name 1–2 canon facts out loud — names, location, the key action — so everyone is on the same page.

  2. Time choice. Ask the audience: "Before or after?" Call their decision out loud so players and audience hear it: "Going earlier" or "Going later."

  3. "Before" scene. Show the causes and setup behind the events. Fill in circumstances, plant details that pay off later — but never contradict what has already been established.

  4. "After" scene. Play out consequences and raise the stakes. Lean on callbacks to details the audience already knows. The fun here is seeing how far the ripples go.

  5. Editing and pace. Keep each chunk to 45–90 seconds. If bits start repeating or energy dips — sharp cut, new time vote. Don't let a segment overstay its welcome.

  6. Reset. When a storyline is spent, grab a fresh suggestion from the audience and launch the next base scene with a new pair or group.

Key rules

  • Keep the opening scene simple and specific (who/where/what) — an overloaded start makes every time jump harder to follow.

  • In 'before' scenes plant causes; in 'after' scenes play consequences. Never rewrite the canon of the base scene.

  • Maintain pace: 45–90 seconds per chunk, sharp cuts, clear transitions — let the story breathe but never drag.

  • The host calls the audience's choice out loud and with conviction; if energy stalls, announce a fresh base scene without apologizing.

  • A quick recap of key facts before each cut reduces name and detail confusion and keeps the whole team aligned on the timeline.

Context